Earlier this year I wrote that AI is the new operating system for nonprofits. I still believe that. But I’ve spent the months since then watching nonprofit leaders actually try to use it, and I’ve noticed something the “AI will change everything” conversation tends to skip.
AI doesn’t make people better at their jobs. It multiplies whatever they bring to it.
That’s a very different claim, and it has very different implications for how you build your team, how you train your staff, and what you personally need to learn over the next year or two.
What a Multiplier Actually Does
Think about what a multiplier is. Multiply three by ten and you get thirty. Multiply zero by ten and you still get zero.
AI works the same way. Hand it to a development director who knows major gifts inside and out, who knows what a strong cultivation plan looks like and can tell a good case for support from a weak one, and that person can now produce the output of a two- or three-person shop. She can draft the appeal, build the segmentation plan, write the grant narrative, prep for the donor meeting, and clean up the board report before lunch, at a level of quality that used to take a team a week.
Hand the same tools to someone who doesn’t know what good fundraising looks like, and you get something else entirely. You get more output, faster, and most of it is wrong in ways that person can’t see.
The Two Kinds of Expertise You Need
Using AI well as a nonprofit leader requires two separate kinds of knowledge, and to be successful, you need both at the same time.
The first is subject area expertise. You have to know your craft, whether that’s fundraising, operations, finance, or nonprofit management. You need to know what a good answer looks like before you ask the question, because AI will give you a confident, polished answer whether it’s right or not.
A fundraiser with 15 years of experience reads an AI-drafted appeal and immediately spots that the ask is buried in paragraph six and the story is about the organization instead of the donor. A novice reads the same draft and thinks it looks great.
The second is AI expertise. This is not the same as having a ChatGPT account. It means knowing how to brief these tools the way you’d brief a smart new hire, with the context, examples, and constraints they need to do the job well. It means knowing how to break a big project into pieces, how to check the work, and which tasks AI does badly while sounding brilliant.
Most people have one or the other. Very few have both. And without both, many nonprofits end up with slower, sloppier work.
What Happens When You Have Only One
I’ve seen both failure modes up close…
The experienced fundraiser who never learned the tools treats AI like a slightly smarter search engine. She types a one-line request, gets a generic draft, decides AI “isn’t very good,” and goes back to writing everything from scratch. She’s right that the output was bad. She’s wrong about why.
The tech-savvy staffer who never learned fundraising does the opposite. He builds elaborate prompts and workflows and produces an enormous amount of material, from donor emails and grant applications to social posts and stewardship letters, and it all looks professional. None of it is built on real fundraising strategy, so the appeals don’t convert, the grants don’t get funded, and the donors don’t feel known.
Worse, because the volume went up, the organization now spends more time reviewing and fixing weak work than it did when one person wrote everything by hand. In both cases, AI made the organization slower, not faster. A multiplier applied to the wrong inputs costs you time.
The Leader Who Has Both
Now picture the entrepreneurial nonprofit leader who has both.
He knows fundraising cold. He also knows how to work with AI the right way, giving it his case for support, his donor data, his past appeals, and his voice, so that what comes back sounds like his organization and reflects real strategy. He treats the first draft as raw material for his own judgment.
That person is a force multiplier. He runs the major gifts program, the annual fund, and the grant pipeline at a level that used to require three staff members, and he does it without burning out, because the drafting and the research are no longer eating his week. What’s left for him is the part only a human can do: the relationships, the asks, the judgment calls, the leadership.
This is where the sector is heading. The organizations that thrive over the next decade will be led by people who are excellent at their jobs and excellent at using AI, and who understand that those are two different skills that only pay off when they’re combined.
What This Means for You
If you lead a nonprofit, don’t go looking for an “AI person” to add to your team. And don’t assume your most experienced people will figure the tools out on their own.
Instead, invest in both halves. Keep building real fundraising expertise, in yourself and in your staff, because that expertise is what makes AI output worth anything. Then take the time to learn these tools properly: not a one-hour webinar, but hands-on practice with real work until you know what they’re good at and where they fall apart.
The multiplier is already here. What it multiplies is up to you!
Photo Credit: flutie8211 from Pixabay
